[Reviews - 223] starstarstarstarstarPrinter
Summary: Could best be described as Lassiter Vs. Seamus McTiernan. A trip to Cleveland goes horribly awry when Lassiter meets his fear darrig doppelgänger. Inspired by Luck of the Irish. Featuring Rebecca Williams! Takes place a month or so after Witness Protection. 
Rated: E
Categories: Alternate Universe Characters: Gus, Juliet, Lassiter, OFC, Other, Shawn
Genres: Drama, General, Hurt/Comfort, Romance
Warnings: None
Challenges: Lassie Face!, "2 For the Price of 1"
Challenges: Lassie Face!, "2 For the Price of 1"
Series: Witness Protection
Chapters: 91 Completed: Yes
Word count: 56820 Read: 785732
Published: July 25, 2012 Updated: December 03, 2012
Story Notes:
Welcome to my first real sequel! I highly recommend reading Witness Protection before this one. :-)
Disclaimer: I do not own Psych, nor do I own any of its characters, settings, trademarks, or related material. Psych and all related materials are the property of their respective owners. The plot and original characters of this story are my intellectual property. I am not associated with Psych, its creators, or any involved parties. No copyright infringement is intended.

Also, I do not own The Luck of the Irish, its plot or characters, and no copyright infringement is intended there, either.

1. Chapter 1 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 22] starstarstarstarstar (372 words)

2. Chapter 2 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (537 words)
A funny scene with Lassiter. Shawn and Gus are on their way! ;/)

3. Chapter 3 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (624 words)
Shawn, Gus, and Juliet enter the picture!

4. Chapter 4 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (573 words)
We meet Seamus McTiernan!

5. Chapter 5 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (1073 words)

6. Chapter 6 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (986 words)
More about doppelgängers. And we find out where Lassiter is taking Becca.

7. Chapter 7 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (660 words)
Our protagonists try to catch an arsonist. And pizza. Seamus will be back soon, as will Gus!

8. Chapter 8 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (589 words)
An awkward conversation, some mushy stuff, teeny bit of Shules. I'm mainly setting up the stage for later conversations in this chapter. Hope you like it! :/)

9. Chapter 9 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (616 words)
We begin our triple date. The beginning of another awkward moment.

10. Chapter 10 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (478 words)
What I think is a nice, fun conversation. Some '80s movie trivia. :/)

11. Chapter 11 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (843 words)
Night falls in Cleveland. There is a conversation that I've been envisioning since before I wrote the rest of the story, and this chapter brings us very close to this conversation.

12. Chapter 12 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 0] starstarstarstarstar (551 words)
The beginning of the big conversation I've been planning! This actually came out a lot different than I originally expected, but I think it's pretty good. :)

13. Chapter 13 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarhalf-star (525 words)
A very interesting conversation. An awkward moment or two.

14. Chapter 14 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarhalf-star (469 words)
Continuing the previous scene. Morning comes.

15. Chapter 15 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarhalf-star (563 words)
A fun phone conversation that may or may not foreshadow for a later story I have planned. Also, some fun with Lassifrass! ;/)

16. Chapter 16 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (968 words)
More fun with Lassiter! Also, be prepared for some Shules next chapter, because although I much prefer writing about Lassiter, I really want to write Shules just to say I did it. You have been warned. :-)

A Note: I have edited this chapter and added in a section that tries to explain why Rebecca contradicted herself in her morning conversation with Lassiter. I also added in a Star Trek reference. :-)

17. INTERLUDE by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (336 words)
This chapter really has little to do with the rest of the story. It is Juliet's flashback that was alluded to at the end of the last chapter. This is my attempt at Shules! I've sort of put everyone but Lassiter and Rebecca on the back burner in this story, and I'd like to make up for that, at least in part, with this! Enjoy!

18. Chapter 17 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstar (914 words)
This chapter came out waaaay different than I planned. Originally, the antagonist character in this chapter was a nameless plot complication. But I had to make him human. So here he is!.

19. Chapter 18 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarhalf-star (458 words)
Becca lives!

20. Chapter 19 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (598 words)
These next few chapters have been reworked a couple times an are different than I originally planned. I think this version has the best interactions between Lassiter and Seamus. Let me know what you think! :-)

21. Chapter 20 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (517 words)
A quick note about doppelgängers: all I know about them, I learned from Nancy Drew: The Captive Curse. So obviously, there may be an inaccuracy. Sometime in the next couple chapters, I (or rather, Becca) will explain the legend in more detail, but it is touched upon here.

22. Chapter 21 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (558 words)
More about doppelgängers and curses. Setting the stage for a good Lassiter moment later in the story. An unexpected request.

23. Chapter 22 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstar (450 words)
This is a shorter chapter, but I wanted to get something posted for the day. An awkward situation gets more awkward and Rebecca quotes William Blake. :-)

24. Chapter 23 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (665 words)
The man beneath the surfboard is revealed. Many quotes from Billy Joel's "We Didn't Start The Fire." I have a very good Lassiter moment planned for the future. :-)

25. Chapter 24 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (459 words)
A wee bit of a scuffle. Juliet breaks it up. A quirky Star Trek reference! I recommend looking up the episode "Amok Time." :-)

26. Chapter 25 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (426 words)
We find out exactly what the deal is with Arsonist Guy. Becca gets suspicious. If things go according to plan, there's a Lassiter moment that should be coming up in the next few chapters! :-) :-)

27. Chapter 26 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarhalf-star (579 words)
Arsonist Guy finds his voice. The anticipated Lassiter moment comes next chapter! Band geeks will be pleased by the music reference in this chapter, I think. :-)

28. Chapter 27 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstar (356 words)
This is a shorter chapter, and the Lassiter moment is not quite what I hoped it would be, but I wanted to post something because I'll be offline for a few days. So enjoy! :-)

29. Chapter 28 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (610 words)
On the trail of Red Jacket Guy! The crime started out as nothing mote than a plot complication, but I'm working on making it into more of a real mystery. The crimes are less important to me than putting the characters in odd places, in case you hadn't noticed! The arson was nothing more than an excuse to get Lassiter to Lake Erie. :-D But I'll try to add crime mystery to the overall mystery of the whole doppelgänger thing. :-) Also, is it getting cold in here, or is it just me?

30. Chapter 29 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (257 words)
Short chapter again, I'm afraid, but fear not! There is a lot more to come, and many exciting things will happen with Lassiter! :-)

31. Chapter 30 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (641 words)
We begin to find out what's happening to Rebecca!

32. Chapter 31 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (640 words)
This is what I feel is a really good Lassiter moment. In fact, I am so pleased with this chapter that I literally could not wait until tomorrow to post it! So I truly hope that you enjoy reading it as much as I enjoyed writing it! I feel like this is the "Giannini moment" of LCL. The scary thing is, I have even more good ones planned!

33. Chapter 32 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (569 words)
When it rains, it pours!

34. Chapter 33 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 0] (999 words)
We find out what's going down with Rebecca, what Buzz is going to do with his new knowledge, and exactly what Sneaky Seamus is up to. As for Lassiter? He's not happy.

35. Chapter 34 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (673 words)
Rebecca tries to let Seamus down easy, Arsonist Guy gets in trouble, and things begin to spiral out of control. Prepare for major awesomeness in the upcoming chapters! ;-) Well, I guess I should say prepare for what I hope is major awesomeness. Sometimes what sounds really awesome in my head isn't always awesome in actuality. And I have an odd definition of awesome, anyway. So prepare for anything!

36. Chapter 35 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (390 words)
Okay! I think there will be major awesomeness beginning...now. I'm still trying to figure out how the awesomeness is going to translate from my head onto the page. Just think of it as a movie; that's the best advice I can give you. :-D

37. Chapter 36 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (798 words)

38. Chapter 37 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (458 words)
Shorter chapter today, but I wanted to post something. I'm a little worried about this chapter (I've never described a dance fight before! I'm wondering what I got myself into!) but I think it works. Also, I referenced an '80s movie in this chapter, but I've never actually seen it. I Googled "Lassiter" and that's what came up, so if it's a bad movie, I cannot be blamed. :-D

39. Chapter 38 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (585 words)

40. Chapter 39 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (340 words)
Shorter chapter, but I hate to let too many days go by without posting. Enjoy! And prepare for an interesting mental image next chapter! :-)

41. Chapter 40 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (805 words)
This chapter quotes Sisters from White Christmas. I do not own White Christmas, nor am I associated with its creators or Irving Berlin, etc. If you have never seen White Christmas, well...Shame on you, because you should! And I strongly recommend that you look up Bing Crosby and Danny Kaye and the Sisters song, because unless you have
watched that specific scene from the movie, you will not get this chapter. But enjoy! :-)

42. Chapter 41 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (622 words)
Sorry this story has been off the air for a couple days. I'll get back to work on it, I promise! I'm really pleased with this chapter. Prepare for Lassiter goodness in the future. Also, be warned that even though this feels like the end, due to my poor planning, it's not. We still have a criminal to catch. And Lassiter goodness. And also possibly a therapy session. And Natira will make one last appearance, I think, so I hope no one forgot her. :-D

43. Chapter 42 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (474 words)
You guys are either going to laugh at this or you'll want to throw a pillow at my head. Not sure which. Don't worry. It'll get better. Or worse, depending on your viewpoint. :-D

44. Chapter 43 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (780 words)
This is another chapter that will make you laugh or throw a pillow at my head. It might also bore you to death, but some of it is a little useful because it sets up an event that will come later in the story. I have here referenced the movie Elizabethtown and several country music artists.

45. Chapter 44 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (386 words)
This sums up the whole mystery. Not that there was much of it to begin with. I'm more interested in the Seamus moment that's coming up soon and the Lassiter moments I am absolutely looking forward to! :-)

46. Chapter 45 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (687 words)
This chapter came out much differently than I had planned. All of the last few chapters sort of took me by surprise. Lassiter and Rebecca keep wanting to argue, but I'm not ready for them to argue yet, so I keep having to rework things and tell them to keep a lid on it! So there is a bit of tension in this chapter. Just don't panic. :-)

47. Chapter 46 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (426 words)

48. Chapter 47 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (644 words)
Well, this came out absolutely nothing like I'd planned! But I think it's still okay. And the scary part is, I may or may not have even more insanity planned before this is over!

49. Chapter 48 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (568 words)
Okay, after hours of thought, deliberation, and haranguing marniewings and iknow (aka 72!) for their opinions, I have finally decided what I'm going to do with this story! Yay! --huge sigh of relief-- So! Be ready for major plot complications! ;-)

50. Chapter 49 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (846 words)

51. Chapter 50 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (620 words)
I will give a figurative cookie to anyone who notices the movie reference in this chapter. :-)

52. Chapter 51 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (289 words)
Sorry to take so long on the update! I rewrote this section several times, but I think I finally have it where I want it. Thanks for your patience! :-)

53. Chapter 52 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (407 words)

54. Chapter 53 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (487 words)
This wasn't at all what I had originally planned, but I like Lassiter fluff and I had fun writing this, so enjoy! :-)

55. Chapter 54 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 4] starstarstarstarstar (523 words)

56. Chapter 55 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (550 words)

57. Chapter 56 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (758 words)
Seamus is getting diabolical again, Lassiter's very angry, and I love making Eoin Colfer references! :-)

58. Chapter 57 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] (707 words)
A grand argument. Lassiter's very angry. :-)

59. Chapter 58 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (613 words)
All right! I had a productive night's brainstorming and wrote two chapters, so here's one of them. Things are getting close to a big Lassiter moment, and also I quoted Huey Lewis' "Do You Believe In Love." :-)

60. Chapter 59 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 4] starstarstarstarstar (674 words)
I wasn't actually going to post this until tomorrow morning, but I had a productive day, and for once, I'm a chapter ahead! Unfortunately, when I'm a chapter ahead, I have a sad tendency to post everything I have at once. So you get one---just one!---chapter early. :-D Now. This is where things get tricky. I tried to make the following scenes as coherent as possible, but I still fear that horrible evil, Implausibility. But seriously, I'm writing about fake psychics, leprechauns, and a klutzy girl who just so happens to get herself romantically involved with the head detective. If you haven't cranked up your Willing Suspension of Disbelief as high as it will go, this story train probably isn't for you! :-D

61. Chapter 60 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (661 words)
Morning, everyone! I hope you're ready, because this is the moment we've all been waiting for! I'm so happy I can finally get this out of my head! :-D Okay. You need to listen to Elvis' song The Wonder of You. Or at least look up the lyrics. It's crucial to understanding the chapter. :-)

62. Chapter 61 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (537 words)
Creepy Shawn and Lassiter fun. :-)

63. Chapter 62 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (522 words)

64. Chapter 63 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (458 words)
This chapter is just some funny fluffy stuff. It's a transition chapter. Just bear with me. :-)

65. Chapter 64 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (347 words)
A little banter, and Lassiter is unhappy. I had such writer's block when I was working on this! But I think I've cleared it up now. :-) While looking up quotes for inspiration, I found an interesting one from Last Night Gus. I've not seen that episode yet, but I did reference the event implied in the quote. I don't think that the brief mention qualifies as a spoiler, but I'm warning you either way. :-)

66. Chapter 65 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (785 words)

67. Chapter 66 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] starstarstarstarhalf-star (528 words)
Shorter chapter this time. Sorry! But don't worry. It looks like this story is going to be a LOT longer than I planned. I know I had you all geared up for the denouement and end, but... I got an idea from someone --pokes marniewings-- that I just couldn't resist. So it's not the end at all yet. And I started my resolution a bit to early as the result of tacking on something I hadn't planned, so I'm sorry if the flow isn't quite what it should be. I'll try to show more restraint with the next story, I promise! :-D But either way, thanks to everyone who has donated these great ideas. I love picking your brains, so keep 'em coming! :-D And I hope you end up enjoying the elongated story. :-)

68. Chapter 67 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (632 words)
Becca and Lassie go to the Bluegrass State. Which is actually a commonwealth. ...Yeah, it's complicated. :-D

69. Chapter 68 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (508 words)
This chapter is another transition chapter. It doesn't add much to the plot, but it was fun for me to write. I'm sorry if it feels like this section is being dragged out forever, but I'm getting there, I promise! I just need a little time to finish my game plan. :-) There will be another major conflict before the story is over, I promise! A cookie for anyone who finds the Luck of the Irish reference. :-)

70. Chapter 69 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarhalf-star (680 words)
Getting closer... :-)

71. Chapter 70 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] starstarstarstarstar (644 words)
Lassiter meets Becca's mama! Ha ha ha! :-) I will say this, though: describing Lassiter's facial expressions is one of the hardest things in the world to do. I'm not sure if I should shake my fist and yell, "Curse you, Timothy Omundson," or if I should fall down on my knees and cry, "I'm not worthy!" :-D

72. Chapter 71 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (392 words)
Okay, so I'm still working on getting to the good part! We're on the way, so never fear! Be ready to meet Becca's uncle next chapter! :-)

73. Chapter 72 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (745 words)
I would just like to say that the disclaimer that Rebecca gives Lassiter about her uncle applies to you readers as well. Her uncle is based on my real-life uncle, so I wrote what my uncle would actually say. I know that some of what my uncle would say is disparaging at best and that some of it is downright untrue, but just remember that I'm writing a character, not a self-insert. I don't think anyone would be offended by this chapter, but there is a remark about politics, and I know how up-in-arms people can get about that sort of thing, so I wanted to cover all of my bases just in case. But I think you all are an open-minded group of people who'll think I'm crazy for worrying, so... Just enjoy reading, okay? And remember that Lassiter once punched Shawn for saying Reagan was a bad president. :-D

74. Chapter 73 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (1168 words)
This chapter was such a blast for me to write. If you enjoy reading it half as much as I enjoyed writing it, my labors will not have been in vain! This was my first attempt at writing a Lassiter Debacle, if that gives any indication!
Also, the next chapter will contain some major clues as to what is going to happen to Rebecca later, so keep your eyes open! ;-)

75. Chapter 74 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (1023 words)
In this chapter, there is a clue as to what will happen when Seamus inevitably returns. There is also a red herring. I will give a figurative cookie to anyone who correctly guesses what they are. :-) Hopefully, there will be a nice Lassiter moment next chapter.

76. Chapter 75 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (615 words)
This is a shorter chapter, but I think I squeezed in a nice little bit of Lassiter fluff and Rebecca invokes Eleanor Roosevelt. :-)

77. Chapter 76 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (676 words)
Another kind of cute Lassiter moment. I'm about to go into a digression that probably won't add much to the actual plot of the story, but I think it'll freak Lassiter out some, and I will enjoy writing that. :-D Not much longer to wait for Seamus---just a few more chapters!

78. Chapter 77 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (728 words)
I had some fun writing this chapter. It's just a little fluff, really. It's meant to be some comedy. Not all that great. But we're getting very close to conflict! :-)

79. Chapter 78 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (728 words)
Another fluff chapter that I had way too much fun writing! I know I promised you conflict, but I have found so much potential for comic relief...! But fear not, conflict will come, and it will be soon. Just perhaps a couple chapters later than I'd planned due to this glorious brain-pop. :-)

80. Chapter 79 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (870 words)
Okay... I used a word in this chapter that I generally dislike using... You see, this is how much I care about you guys. I hope you think this is funny, because I do this solely for your amusement. Well, okay, I do it in part for my own amusement, too. But this particular chapter? Mostly for you all. Especially marniewings, because she knows how...peculiar I am. :-D So enjoy the Doctor Who quote! And the word that has so far appeared just this once out of all of my stories! Also, unless craziness occurs, we'll have Seamus back next chapter! :-)

81. Chapter 80 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (1068 words)
Writing this chapter felt like a breath of fresh air. I am so positive and excited about this for some reason! I hope you all are, too. :-)

82. Chapter 81 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (781 words)
Seamus is back, and as wicked as ever!!

83. Chapter 82 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (526 words)
Rebecca gets left behind! Also, this story has broken 50,000 words, making it officially the longest story I've ever written! Yay! :-)

84. Chapter 83 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (909 words)
This might be a bit anticlimactic. But it will get better.

85. Chapter 84 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (541 words)
This chapter... I am not sure about it. You will note that Rebecca has a bigger reaction to these events than she did to Seamus. I think it is because I scared myself while writing it... Don't judge me. :-D

86. Chapter 85 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 1] (607 words)
Sorry it took so long to post this, but I had some writer's block and a holiday to get through. By the way, Happy Thanksgiving! I'm thankful for writing, creativity, Psychfic, and all you guys. :-) Many thanks to marniewings for all her help, particularly for helping me brainstorm and suggesting the ideas to include Becca's family, to have Seamus kidnap Rebecca, and to create the events of the next few chapters. :-)

87. Chapter 86 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (509 words)
Banter! :-D

88. Chapter 87 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (499 words)
More fun banter, and some concrete proof that Becca controls Lassiter, not vice versa. Well, most of the time, anyway. I might add in something to balance this. The next story I'm planning will definitely balance this, I think. Mwa ha ha! (smiles knowingly at unsuspecting victims---er, readers...)

89. Chapter 88 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 2] (576 words)
I feel pretty good about this chapter. We find out what the Celtic thingy does in a nutshell, and what Lassiter has to do. And also, Lassiter is a wee bit insecure. (Yes, I just said "wee bit." Don't judge me. It is a story about leprechauns, after all!)

90. Chapter 89 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (780 words)
Not quite as epic as I'd planned, but --shrugs-- sometimes the characters just won't go where you send them. I think it still came out fairly well, though. :-)
Unfortunately, though, this does mean we are nearing the end. It will be a few more chapters of denouement, and then we'll be done. --sniffles-- But then, on to the next story! :-) So thanks to everyone for reading and sticking with me thus far!

91. Chapter 90 by PineappleHead [Reviews - 3] starstarstarstarstar (1208 words)
This chapter is the last chapter, but it is also sort of an epilogue. That's right, my friends. This is it. The finale. El fin. Al fine without the da Capo. I hope it is as slam-bang as it needs to be, and I'm sorry I made you all wait so long. I really didn't know how to end it when it came down to it, so I hope I did it right. Thank you all so much for reading, because you don't know how much it means to me. And please read the next story that I plan to post. Live long and prosper! :-)